North Dakota Supreme Court April 27, 1916 (Helman v. Strong)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-1916

Fisk, Ch. J.

Action to recover upon a $300 note executed and delivered by defendant to plaintiff; also to recover $400 and interest on account for moneys claimed to have been loaned by plaintiff to defendant. Plaintiff had judgment in the lower court, pursuant to the verdict, in the sum of $700 with interest at 8 per cent on the note only, and for costs. The reason that interest was not allowed on the $400 item evidently is because of an erroneous instruction to the effect that the allowance of interest thereon was a matter of discretion with the jury. The giving of such instruction was no doubt the result of mere inadvertence on the part of the learned trial court, and had his attention been called thereto, as it should have been, he undoubtedly would have corrected the error. The respondent, however, is the party prejudiced thereby, and he has not seen fit to complain or to ask the trial court to amend the verdict and judgment so as to include interest thereon at the legal rate.

The specifications of error are all aimed at rulings and instructions appertaining to the first cause of action, which involves the $300 note. Hence the verdict and judgment, in so far as the second cause of action is concerned, cannot be disturbed. True, near the close of appellant’s brief, counsel say: “It is true that the note constituted but one of the *231causes of action alleged in plaintiff’s complaint. Both causes were, however, submitted to the jury at the same time, and the verdict is for a lump sum, from which it is impossible to calculate just how much was allowed upon the note and what sum upon the account for money loaned. The bundle of letters was also entirely irrelevant to the issues presented by the second cause of action; and deficiency in the charge of the court on that point would he as prejudicial to defendant upon the second cause of action as the first.” We deem this contention unsound.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.