Indiana Supreme Court February 4, 1916, No. 22,804 (Union Fraternal League v. Sweeney)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1916

Morris, C. J.

Action by appellee against appellant on a policy of insurance for $1,000, issued by appellant on tbe life of appellee’s husband, and payable to appellee. Appellant answered tbe complaint in three paragraphs, tbe first of which was a general denial. Tbe second and third denied liability because of alleged fraud in procuring tbe policy. There was a trial by jury, and verdict and judgment for appellee. Appellant assigns error on tbe overruling of its motion for judgment on tbe jury’s answers to interrogatories submitted, and *380overruling its motion for a new trial. There is no irreconcilable conflict between the general verdict and the facts specially found.

Appellant contends that there is reversible error disclosed by the court’s instructions to the jury. The complaint alleges in general termst hat appellee performed all the conditions of the contract which were therein required of her to be performed, but makes no reference therein of the waiver by appellant of the performance of any condition. One of appellant’s rules, constituting a part of the contract, reads as follows:

“All claims for death benefits shall require the affidavits of the claimant, attending or family physician, undertaker, friends or such others (or such of them) as are clearly necessary to establish the claim, and said affidavits shall be upon the forms of blanks furnished by the board of trustees, and are required to be fully answered, and until full proof be received as required, the order shall not be bound to take any action upon the claim.”

The evidence shows that there was not a strict compliance with the above condition. The proof submitted to appellant contained neither an affidavit by appellee nor one by the attending physician. Before the filing of appellant’s answers it denied liability on the policy and tendered to appellee the full amount of assessments or premiums paid.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.