Supreme Court of Iowa January 13, 1916 (Burrell v. Waterloo, Cedar Falls & Northern R. Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-01-1916
Evans, C. J.
*442Eminent domain: nature of proceeding: way: ad quod damnum to enforce. donate*r?ght°of. *441The statutory proceedings herein were instituted by the defendant railway company against the *442plaintiff as tlie owner of land desired for railway right of way purposes. The damages were first appraised by a sheriff’s jury as provided by statute, Brom this award, the plaintiff appealed to the district court. An increased award was allowed by the verdict of the jury in the district court, and a judgment for costs was entered against the defendant. On the trial in the district court, the defendant offered to prove by the testimony of one O’Neil and other witnesses that, prior to the location of the defendant’s right of way over the land of the plaintiff, such line of location was solicited by the plaintiff; and, in consideration therefor, the plaintiff agreed to “permit the occupancy of the said lands without the payment of damages therefor”. To this line of evidence, the plaintiff objected as incompetent, irrelevant and immaterial, and not pertinent to any issue in the case. This objection was sustained. The one question presented for our consideration on this appeal is whether such evidence was admissible in an ad quod damnum proceeding.
The appellant relies at this point upon our former cases of Corbin v. Wisconsin I. & N. R. Co., 66 Iowa 269, and Keokuk & N. W. R. Co. v. Donnell, 77 Iowa 221, wherein similar testimony was held admissible. In each of these cases, the railway company had acquired peaceable possession of its right of way under an alleged agreement with the owner concerning compensation. Ignoring such agreement, the land owner afterward instituted ad quod damnum proceedings. It was held in each of such cases that it was permissible to the railway company to show such agreement in defense of the proceeding instituted by the landowner. The argument here is that, if such evidence was admissible in those cases, it is admissible herein.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit