Court of Appeals of Kentucky April 20, 1916 (Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. Witte)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-04-1916

*569Opinion op the Court by

Judge Carroll.

Affirming.

The appellee, an employe of the appellant railway company, sustained personal injuries on account of its negligence, and in a suit for damages had a judgment for $1,375.00.

A reversal is asked on two grounds; first, that the verdict is excessive; and, second, misconduct on the part of counsel for appellee in the argument of the case.

The injury complained of consisted of a cut on the right leg above the knee about seven inches long, and from a half inch to an inch in depth, together with some bruises. He was confined to his room for about six weeks with his leg propped on a chair, and after this he walked about on crutches for about six weeks. The trial occurred a year after the injuiy, and there was some evidence that his leg was yet sore, and the locomotion or movement of the leg somewhat impaired, accompanied by a sensation of numbness.

The medical evidence for the company was to the effect that the wound had healed without leaving any bad effects.

A consideration of the record on the subject of appellee’s injury inclines us to the opinion that the damages are larger than should have been assessed, but at the same time we cannot say that the assessment is so flagrantly against the evidence as to authorize us to order a new trial on this ground. The mere fact that a jury awards larger damages than we think the injury justified does not authorize us to interfere with the verdict. ,

On the trial of the case, during the examination of Dr. Eobertson, a witness for appellee, and who attended him as a physician, he said that after making two or three visits he turned appellee over to Dr. Franz, who, he said, was at the time the assistant surgeon for the appellant company. Counsel for appellee asked the court to exclude from the jury the statement that Dr. Franz was the assisted surgeon for the railway company, and this motion was sustained, the jury being instructed not to consider the evidence of Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.