District Court, S.D. New York April 3, 1916 (Anchor Cap & Closure Corp. v. Pritchard)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-04-1916

LEARNED HAND, District Judge.

There are four patents here in suit which should be treated separately.

Patent 770,751.

[ 1 ] This patent has ,no predecessors, except Kalling’s two patents, 561,792 and 697,491. They differed from Hull’s disclosure, because the bead was deformed by squeezing it against the side of the glass. It makes no difference whether the gasket was of a hard enough con - sistency, so that the nearest edges of the bead never touched the glass, or whether it collapsed so far that a part of the pressure was between metal and glass. In either case, the glass had to hear the whole of a pressure sufficient to deform the bead. It is, perhaps, not surprising, therefore, that Hull should have testified that the breakage when he witnessed the test ran as high as 60 per cent., although the patentee was giving a demonstration in the hopes of a sale. ''Phis evidence, coupled with the fact that no commercial use of the patent has ever been made, makes the conclusion reasonable that the patent was impractical.

1 therefore find, first, that the disclosure operated upon a different principle from the patent in suit; and, second, that it is invalid in any case, because it did not contribute to the art a practical device.

The next question is of infringement, and this turns, altogether upon whether, in the defendant’s cap, the bead’s “upper and lower inner walls firmly bind against the upper and lower surfaces of a peripheral portion of said ring, and hold squeezed from said groove the other peripheral portion of said ring.” The defendant’s bead, upon their own statement, “holds squeezed from said groove the other peripheral portion of said ring”; the only question is whether “the upper and lower walls firmly bind against the upper and lower surfaces.” If this clause means that it must be only because of the approach vertically of the upper and lower walls that the gasket is extruded from its former position, then I agree that the defendant does not infringe.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.