District Court, S.D. New York May 15, 1916, Equity 13-75 (Baldwin Co. v. R. S. Howard Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1916

HOUGII, District Judge

(after stating the facts as above). The cancellation proceedings above referred to were brought long before this suit, and the record herein largely consists of the evidence taken in the Patent Office by both parties. It is exceedingly voluminous, and descends into great detail. About these details there is that uncertainty, if not contradiction in nonessentials, which must always be the case when even intelligent and well-intentioned men testify regarding occurrences of many years ago.

After perusing the entire record, however, I am of opinion that as to all relevant facts (in the sense of visible or audible phenomena) there is almost no difference between the parties hereto. .Contradictions exist, but they are rather in the inferences to be drawn from what was said or written, than in respect of the happening of this or that event. I shall therefore make the findings of fact herein comparatively brief.

Mr. Robert S. Howard began his active career as a piano tuner in Ohio about 1877. Pie plainly developed ability far beyond the usual as a salesman, until in 1889, when he entered the employment of the New Ping-land Piano Company of Boston, I have no doubt that Mulcahy (one of the principal employes of the New England concern) testified accurately when he said that, though he had never before met Mr. Howard, he had known of him for years as a piano salesman and traveler, and “we” (the New England people) “all congratulated ourselves on making the connection with him.” Nor is it doubted that Mr. Gibbs of Chicago, who has known Howard for a long time, correctly described him as a “very popular and prominent traveler and well liked by the trade.”

The New England Company manufactured pianos in a Boston factory, one entrance to which was on Howard street.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.