District Court, D. Oregon December 18, 1916, No. 4757 (The Indrapura)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-12-1916
WOLVERTON, District Judge.
What has previously been determined on exceptions to the libel in this case I find no occasion for *854amending or modifying. By averment in the libel it appears that the-steamship Indrapura was put in dry dock without maritime necessity therefor. Controverting this averment, two of the respondents answer that it is true the Indrapura was put into dry dock with a partial' cargo on board, but that this was done in pursuance of a usage and custom which was general as to the port of Hong Kong and the ports of the Orient and of the world, and that such usage and custom, as it respects the port of Hong Kong, has its basis upon the conditions that prevail and have prevailed for a great length of time relating to the shipment and transshipment of cargo. The sole question that now arises is, what effect such usage and custom, if it exists, has as it respects the bills of lading or the policy of insurance of freight by the ■ British & Foreign Marine Insurance Company. This question is not dominated in the least particular by the former opinion of this court on the exceptions to the libel.
Pertaining to the question of fact as to whether the alleged usage- and custom exists, I am persuaded that it does, and that it has so existed for a long period of time as it relates' to the port of Hong Kong; but the proofs are inadequate to show that it exists in the Orient generally or in other ports of the world. It was the common practice in the transshipment of cargo for ships to discharge in the stream upon lighters, and then reload from the lighters into ships for carrying the-cargo forward on the voyage. There are other means of discharging, cargo for transshipment, namely, by. discharging on wharves, or “go-downs,” as they are called, such cargo being taken from these places of deposit for carriage to destination; but the transshipment is generally accomplished through means and by use of lighters, as above indicated.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit