Supreme Court of the United States March 26, 1917, 269 (California v. Deseret Water, Oil & Irrigation Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-03-1917

*416

Mr. Justice Day

delivered the opinion of the court.

The Deseret Water, Oil & Irrigation Company brought a proceeding in condemnation in the Superior Court of Mono County, California,'against the State of California, to appropriate, by right of eminent domain certain lands in that State, for the purpose of preserving and maintaining water rights, equipping and operating canals, etc., to be used in supplying water and power to mines, farming neighborhoods, cities, and towns and villages, and to corporations and individuals, draining, reclaiming and irrigating lands,' equipping, operating and maintaining ditches, reservoirs, etc., and for the operation and maintenance of pumps and pumping plants, electrical lighting and power plants, and electric and power lines.

The right to make such appropriation was sustained in the Superior Court, but upon appeal this judgment was reversed by the District Court of Appeal for the Third Appellate District. Thereupon, upon motion to the Supreme Court of California, the cause was transferred to that court for hearing and decision, and, upon consideration, the judgment of the Superior Court was affirmed. 167 California, 147. The Supreme Court held that the lands belonged to the State, and that by certain statutes of the State it had been provided that, notwithstanding the ownership of the State, the lands might be appropriated to a public use such as the Water Company was lawfully proposing to make of them, and that as to such matters the State had consented to be sued in the same manner.as any private proprietor might be. A writ of error brings the case to this court.

The land in question is a sixteenth section, passing to the State by virtue of, the federal grant for school purposes. Act of 1853,10 Stat. 244; Act of 1866,14 Start. 218. Afterward, a national reservation, known as the Mono Forest Reserve, was established by proclamation of the President.

*417

This reservation included this section 16 within its boundaries.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.