California Court of Appeal November 26, 1918, Civ. No. 2515. (Richmond Wharf and Dock Co v. Blake)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-11-1918
LENNON, P.
This is an appeal from a judgment for the plaintiff, who is the assignee of the rights of one A. S. Macdonald against the defendant herein.
In 1906 Macdonald was the owner of certain submerged land in the city of Richmond, which land is known as tide lot No. 16, and lies under the waters of the bay of San Francisco. The outer boundary line of said land runs about along the line of what is known as the bulkhead harbor line in the bay of San Francisco as established by the United States Government. The defendant was at that time the owner of the uplands lot lying back of Macdonald’s land. Macdonald and the defendant entered into a contract under which the defendant was to do certain work, such as.building a seawall around and filling in the land owned by Macdonald, and when such work was completed, Macdonald was to convey to the defendant an undivided one-half interest in said land. Five years’ time was given to complete the work, and time was made of the essence of the contract. The defendant failed to complete the work; Macdonald assigned his rights to plaintiff, who sues for damages for breach of contract.
The chief point made by appellant is that the court erred in excluding evidence as to what would have been the value of the land if it had been filled and walled, because such value of one-half of the land was the consideration moving to defendant for the work to be done upon the land, and defendant should be credited with such amount when he is charged with the cost of doing the work which he contracted to do.
The measure of damages upon a breach of a contract like the one under consideration is the difference between the price at which the contractor agreed to do the work and the reasonable cost to the owner of the property of having such work completed.
Evidence was admitted showing the reasonable cost of doing the work as contracted for. The consideration to be paid defendant was one-half of the land after it was filled.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit