Court of Appeals of Texas March 20, 1918, No. 5991. (City of San Antonio v. Terrill)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-03-1918
ELY, C. J.
Appellant sued appellee to recover taxes due on a certain tract or lot of land for the years 1894 to 1912, both inclusive, and on the trial sought to introduce certain copies of the assessments on the land, which for the years 1894 to 1908, inclusive, were made by the city commissioner of taxation. in 1909, but all the assessments were excluded by the court. Appellee made his warrantors parties, and ashed for judgment against them in case judgment should be rendered against him. The cause was tried by jury, and verdict and judgment rendered for appellee. Judgment was also rendered that appellee take nothing as to the warrantors.
The assessments were declared void by the court for the reasons that the land was not described with sufficient certainty to identify it, and that appellee had purchased the land on December 17, 1908, from Mrs. B. E. Horton and the Horton heirs, and as to all taxes before that time was an innocent purchaser, .and obtained the land free of tax liens or tax liability. This suit has been appealed on a ■bill of exceptions as permitted by article 1007, Revised Statutes.
[1]
The first assignment of error assails the action of the court in overruling an exception to that part of appellee’s answer that sought to make the warrantors of appellee parties to the suit. It is contended that it is against public policy to postpone and delay the state in the collection of its taxes, and, if that proposition was well founded, still the record fails to show that impleading the war-rantors caused any delay. There is no premise for the argument made in the brief, and we cannot enter the field of speculation, as appellant would have this court to do, and charge up the delay of over five years from the time the suit was instituted until a trial was had to the warrantors being made parties. Appellant admits that “there is no proof in the record as to the cause of the delay,” and we cannot draw on our imagination to supply such proof.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit