Court of Appeals of Texas January 28, 1918, No. 1900. (Schaff v. Wilson)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-01-1918

LEVY, J.

(after stating the facts as above).

[1]

Appellant insists that the court should have directed, as requested, a verdict in Ms favor because there is no proof showing, or tending to show, that the fire which destroyed the house originated from sparks from the locomotive. In the circumstances the origin of the fire is, it is concluded, a jury question, and the court did not err in passing the issue to the jury for decision. The wife of appellee, being at the time awake, saw the north-bound passenger train as it was passing the house at 12:20 a. m. She testified:

“I could see the engine of the train as it passed. The engine was making a considerable noise in pulling the grade there. There was an unusual amount of sparks being thrown that night. I merely watched the train pass, and noticed it was throwing an unusual amount of fire. The sparks were blowing towards the house. * * * I have watched sparks from the train at night very often. There were more than common that night. Some of them went very high and were light for some distance in the heavens.”

She further testified that shortly after-.wards, “somewhere near 1 o’clock,” she discovered that the house was afire, and it was well under way on the roof and in the ceiling. The wind was high, and blowing directly towards the house from the railway, and the weather was very dry, and had been for

*252

two months. The house was a frame one, with a shingled roof, built in 1909. Mrs. Wilson further testified as follows:

“I didn’t have any fire; the stove had not been put up in the dining room; there had been no heaters put-up in the house. We had two chimneys and the cookstove that were fixed for fires. I had not cooked supper that evening, but had made a chip fire in one corner of the stove and warmed up some gravy. I suppose I had the fire in the cook stove a little before 6; it was before dark. I examined the cook stove before I went to church.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.