Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 15, 1918 (W. A. Case & Son Manufacturing Co. v. Young Improvement Corp.)

Per Curiam:

Plaintiff had supphed plumbing materials to the Midwood Plumbing Company, a contractor with the Young Improvement Company, which was erecting eight apartment houses. *741As a subcontractor, plaintiff had to show that on October 23, 1916, when it had filed and served its notice of lien, there were moneys due the contractor, the Midwood Plumbing Company.