Illinois Supreme Court October 21, 1918, No. 12088 (McLean v. Barnes)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-10-1918

Mr. Justice Cooke

delivered the opinion of the court:

Dora C. McLean, the appellee, filed her bill in the circuit court of McLean county to set aside the last will and testament of her mother, Margaret H. Crumbaker, alleging lack of testamentary capacity. At the time of her death, on September 13, 1917, Mrs. Crumbaker was sixty-three years of age. The will in question was executed on May 24, 1912. The testatrix owned a homestead, consisting of a house and lot in Colfax, and a farm of 120 acres, both in McLean county. By the terms of the will appellee was devised the house and lot in fee simple and a life estate in the residue of the estate, both real and personal. The will then provided that after the death of appellee, and after the youngest child of appellee should become twenty years of age, the remainder should vest in the descendants of the testatrix. The executor was given control of the estate in which appellee was devised a life estate, with power to rent the same and collect the rents, and was directed to pay the net proceeds to appellee, who was the only child of the testatrix. ' The jury found that the purported .will was not the last will and testament of Margaret H. Crumbaker, and a decree was entered setting the will aside. From that decree the executor has prosecuted this appeal.

Appellant contends, first, that the verdict was contrary to the evidence; second, that the court erred in admitting the testimony of an attorney; and third, that the court erred in giving certain instructions asked on behalf of the appellee.

A number of witnesses testified on both sides as to the mental condition of the testatrix, and, as is usual in cases of this kind, the evidence was conflicting. We are of the opinion that the verdict of the jury and the decree of the court are amply supported by a preponderance of the evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.