Michigan Supreme Court July 18, 1918, Docket No. 112 (Brown v. Michigan Railway Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-07-1918
Bird, J.
In the year 1913, plaintiff was a farmer and resided on his farm in Gaines township, Kent county. He was also the owner of another farm in Byron township, which he operated. He traveled from one to the other with his teams and tools over an east and west highway extending through said townships. Early in the spring of 1913 defendants reached this highway in the construction of their interurban railway. The plan of crossing the highway was at right angles and a separation of grades, the highway passing over the railway. Soon after commencing the work the highway became impassable to travelers and as a consequence they veered to the south and went around the construction work. The owner of the land on the south side put an end to this by putting up his fences. Then travelers began to pass around to the north, and later defendants leased ten acres lying immediately north of the intersection to provide a passageway for them around the intersection. On the evening of August 21st plaintiff was returning from the Byron farm to his home with two teams and a lumber wagon. While driving around the construction work and over the leased land in the traveled track the wagon was driven into a deep hole from 18 to 24 inches deep, situate in or near the traveled way. The jolt occasioned thereby threw plaintiff off the wagon and severely injured him.
*282At the conclusion of plaintiff’s proofs defendants requested a directed verdict alleging several grounds therefor. This request was granted and placed upon the ground that plaintiff was a licensee and, therefore, took the temporary road as he found it. Plaintiff complains of this instruction and insists that he was an invitee and not a licensee, and by reason thereof it was the duty of defendants to see- that the temporary way over which he was invited to pass was in a reasonably safe condition for public travel.
1.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit