Supreme Court of Minnesota February 8, 1918, No. 20,738 (City of St. Paul v. Chicago, St. Paul, Minneapolis & Omaha Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-02-1918

Taylor, C.

In 1915 it became necessary to reconstruct the southerly span of the bridge which carries Westminster street in the city of St. Paul over the tracks of defendants, and the city passed an ordinance requiring defendants to rebuild it. They refused to do so, and thereupon the city rebuilt it and then brought this action to recover the expense incurred. The city recoyered a .judgment in the district court and defendants appealed.

The defendants rest their case upon the proposition that the city is estopped and barred from maintaining this action by a judgment entered in the district court on May 17, 1899.

To understand the situation a brief reference to the proceedings which resulted in that judgment is necessary. Pursuant to negotiations between officers of the city and officers of the several railway companies, *324an agreement was formulated, in 1880, which provided that, whenever the city should direct that a street be carried over the tracks of railway companies within the city by a bridge, the railway companies interested should build the abutments for the bridge and the superstructure over their tracks, 'and that the city should build the approaches to the bridge and should maintain the bridge and keep it in repair after it was constructed. By its terms this agreement appears to apply to and include all railway companies having tracks within the city. It was signed by the St. Paul, Minneapolis & Manitoba Railway Company, the predecessor in interest of the Great Northern Railway Company. The original agreement seems to have been lost and whether it was signed by 'any of the other railway companies is not clear and there is no finding as to this fact. It does not appear that the city council ever authorized or directed the execution of the agreement by the city, nor that any city officer ever signed or executed it on behalf of the city. However this may be, the city and the railway companies, or a part of them, proceeded to act under the agreement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.