Wisconsin Supreme Court April 3, 1918 (Marlatt v. Western Union Telegraph Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-04-1918
ViNJE, J.
Upon the question of compensatory damages the court instructed the jury that the elements thereof in this case were “the reasonable value of the information contained in the messages so wrongfully divulged by the defendant, which, according to the uncontradicted evidence, is $45, and such mental suffering as you are satisfied by the credible evidence was endured by the plaintiff, if any, because of anticipation of loss of business,.and loss of prestige or standing as a newspaper correspondent, which you are satisfied might reasonably be apprehended under such circumstances as are shown in this ease as the natural and proximate consequence of the defendant’s wrongful act.” The court correctly held *178that there were no other elements of compensatory damages, for there was no evidence that plaintiff suffered, any financial loss not included in the above elements. He was unable to show the loss of a single contract or engagement, present or prospective, by reason of defendant’s wrongful act other than the value of the messages divulged and his worry or mental anguish over the situation. So the question recurs whether the elements submitted were proper. Plaintiff alleges in his complaint and reiterates again and again in his evidence that his contract with the Free Press was an exclusive one; that he told Miller, the defendant’s agent at Kenosha, that he could not furnish him the scores because his exclusive contract with the Free Press prevented him from letting any one else have them. It is therefore evident that when he delivered the scores to the defendant, the agent selected by the Free Press for transmitting them to it, he surrendered control and possession of the property sold, and he no longer re-táined any property interest therein. Such property interest was in the Free Press, and any divulgence of the contents of the messages was a violation of the property rights of it and not of the plaintiff.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit