District Court, E.D. New York May 13, 1918 (The Trinidad)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-05-1918

CHATFIELD, District! Judge.

The libelant did work totaling $122,940.81, which included a large amount of work extra to that required by the original specifications. This work was- completed and payment demanded on or about the 26th day of February, 1917. The steamer Trinidad, on which the work had been done, was then in the *175Tietjen & Dang Dry Docks in Jersey City, and apparently question was immediately raised as to items totaling $1,096, which the owner of the steamer claimed had been included in the charge, although the work whicli they represented had been omitted by its direction. Prompt payment of the bill was demanded, and there is evidence that a charge of $10Q wharfage per day was threatened if there was delay in payment. The president of the Tietjen & Dang Company, after some discussion, offered to allow the $1,096 above referred to as a deduction, if payment was made at once. The bill was not paid until the 29th day of March, the vessel at that time changing ownership. 'f'he delay in the purchase of the vessel seems to have corresponded to the delay in paying the bill, and at the time of payment two questions were left open, which came up for adjustment. One was the amount of wharfage claimed by Tietjen & Dang, and the other the old item of $1,096, which the owners of the steamship thought should still he allowed. The Tietjen & Dang people have never claimed interest upon the amount of their bill, nor any damages occasioned by their loss of the space occupied by the Trinidad, during this time. Instead of so doing, they have withdrawn the deduction, which was conditioned upon prompt payment, and have fixed the berth charge at a reduced amount of $75 per day, which according to the testimony of one witness was the minimum market rate at that time for a berth of this size.

[1] Dike demurrage, wharfage can be fixed at a market rate which represents the amount of damages, loss of profits, etc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.