Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit April 24, 1918, No. 2345 (Leo Feist, Inc. v. American Music Roll Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-04-1918

McPHERSON, Circuit Judge.

This bill — which was brought by Leo Feist, Incorporated, the owner of certain copyrighted songs that had been reproduced mechanically by the American Music Roll Company — prayed for an account, an injunction, the recovery of royalties, a counsel fee, and treble damages. Royalties were recovered, but the court refused to exercise its discretion on the' subject of counsel fees and damages, holding that the plaintiff had voluntarily licensed the roll company and for that reason could in no event be advantaged by the punitive provisions of Act March 4, 1909, c. 320, 35 Stat. 1075. The appeal raises the single question, whether this refusal was erroneous, and whether the court should have exercised its discretion. Let us first consider tire act, so far as it bears on the mechanical reproduction of music.

In February, 1909, the Supreme Court decided (White-Smith, etc., Co. v. Apollo Co., 209 U. S. 1. 28 Sup. Ct. 319, 52 L. Ed. 655, 14 Ann. Cas. 628) that perforated rolls for the piano were not “copies” within the meaning of the statutes then in force, and suggested that, if (as was true) this condition of the law permitted the mechanical reproduction of musical compositions without the payment of royalty, “such considerations properly address themselves to the legislative and not to the judicial branch of the government.” Congress followed this suggestion, and in the revised act of 1909 provided for the protection of such compositions by giving to the owner the exclusive right (section 1, cl. “e” [Comp. St. 1916, § 9517J) “to make any arrangement or setting of (the composition), or of the melody of it, in any system of notation or any form of record in which the thought of an author may be recorded, and from which it may be read or reproduced.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.