Appellate Court of Illinois October 22, 1918 (Jobst v. City of Danville)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-10-1918

Mr. Justice Graves

delivered the opinion of the court.

The parties to this suit entered into an agreement for the construction of a bridge and the approaches thereto within the limits of appellant city, for the total sum of $80,000. It was all completed, accepted and paid for except the paving of the approaches, and that work had progressed until the concrete base, curb and gutter on the approaches were completed. Almost immediately after the concrete work for this paving job had been completed, the City Council, by resolution, directed appellee to place no brick on the foundation until directed to do so by the City Council, and directed its superintendent of streets to cover the concrete base with gravel or cinders and open the bridge for travel, which order was in all respects complied with. The resolution referred to was adopted November 6, 1916. In January, 1917, this suit was commenced by appellee to recover for the part of the paving work on the approaches to the bridge that had been completed by him. He obtained a judgment for $2,007.10. The city brings the record of that case here by appeal.

Appellant’s defense in the Circuit Court was based primarily on the claim that the concrete pavement was not constructed according to contract. It makes the same contention here and urges as error all rulings of the court by which it was prevented from proving the claim to be true, by members of the City Council and others. The testimony of one witness for appellant on that question was taken out of the presence of the jury, and it offered to prove the same thing by several other witnesses, but the court held the testimony incompetent on the ground that whether or not the work, had been performed according to specification, had been, by the terms of the contract, left to the city engineer of appellant city to determine, and that the only question for the jury was how the engineer had determined it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.