Supreme Court of the United States April 29, 1918, 262 (Bullen v. State of Wisconsin)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-04-1918

Mr. Justice Holmes

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is a proceeding to fix the inheritance tax upon the estate of George Bullen, deceased, a resident of Wisconsin. The Supreme Court of the State affirmed a judgment for a tax upon'a fund of nearly a million dollars which the heirs and next of kin say cannot be taxed in Wisconsin without violating the Fourteenth. Amendment and the contract clause of the Constitution of the United •States. 143 Wisconsin, &12.

The facts are simple. Bullen. formerly had lived in Chicago and continued to do. some business there after moving to Wisconsin, which he did in 1892: He kept in Chicago the bonds, stocks and notes constituting the fund and in 1902 conveyed them to the Northern Trust Company of that City upon certain- trusts. In 1904 by virtue of powers reserved he repossessed himself of the fund, but in 1907 he conveyed it to the company upon the former trusts, again. The limitations, so far as material, were of relatively small sums to a sister and niece residing in Massachusetts, .and, subject to those gifts, of one-third of the income to his widow for life and the rest of the income and the principal to his four sons. But the instrument contained the following clause: “Fifth. I, the donor, expressly reserve the right tb direct and control the disposition of the said trust property and estate, to revoke and vacate this trust at any time during. my life, to enter into and upon and take possession of .the samé, or.any part thereof, to require a reconveyance to. me of the said trust property, or any part thereof, and to dispose of it as I may see fit. During my lifetime.the principal and income shall be used for such beneficiaries

*630

and in such manner as I may from time to time appoint, and in default of any appointment during my lifetime, and, at all events, after my death, the said income and the said principal shall be applied, paid over or held as herein provided.”.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.