Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas December 17, 1919, No. 5580. (Smith v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-12-1919
LATTIMORE, Judge.
—Appellant was convicted in the District Court of Potter County, of the offense of rape, and his punishment fixed at five years in the penitentiary.
Appellant was charged with the rape of one Mary Graham, alleged to be a female under the age of fifteen years.
The record discloses that Mary Graham lived with her mother, older sister, and two younger sisters, in a two-room house in Amarillo, at the time of the alleged commission of this offense, and that she was about twelve or thirteen years of age. Upon the trial the prosecutrix testified very positively to the disgusting and revolting details of the occurrence, fixing its time as being in the morning before breakfast, some time before last Christmas; stating also that her mother was present and consenting to all that was done, and that her mother withdrew into the adjacent room after appellant and prosecutrix had gotten into bed together; and that she gave her mother a part of the money which she says appellant paid to her for such carnal favors. The, proof further shows that the older sister who was only sixteen years of age at the time of this occurrence, was a common prostitute, and that the mother,
*457
who had borne many children, was also at said time one of the same unfortunate class.
The mother testified as a witness for the State, and the sister as a witness for the appellant. While the sister was on the stand testifying, she was asked by the State’s attorney, and stated over objection of appellant, that she was a common prostitute. In this there was no error. She was also asked, and stated over objection of appellant, if she had not had intercourse with appellant, and answered that she had.
While on the witness stand as a witness for himself, appellant was asked if what said witness had stated with regard to having had intercourse with him was true. Objection was made to this, was overruled, and appellant answered that he could not deny it. We think such evidence inadmissible.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit