Supreme Court of the United States January 15, 1919, 136 (Western Pacific Railroad v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1919

*353

Mr. Justice McKenna

-delivered the opinion of the court.

.. -The basic proposition in this case, and most of its subsidiary considerations, are the same as in- No. 134,

ante,

339. It was argued at the same time as the latter case,. and, as in that case, it is to recover amounts withheld by the accounting officers of thé Government .as land-grant deductions in settlements for transportation" óf the personal effects of Army officers..

It is asserted, however, that this , action differs from No. 134' in that the Western Pacific Railroad was not completed and in operation until 1910 so that.it is said “there is absent the element of previous course of dealings relied upon by the Government, and' in that there was introduced in evidence” testimony to the effect that the first voucher -presented for transportation service was for full tariff rates.-

It js stated in the findings that the real claimants in the case áre the receivers of the railroad but that its name is used to .designate claimants for convenience, ánd that between June 10, 1910, and March 18, 1915, the railroad, at the request of the United States as shipper or consignor, received from other railroad companies at connecting points, on government bills of lading, and transported over its lines, the effects and, property of officers of the United States - Army, changing stations under orders.

It further appears that from June 10, 1910, to March 18, 1915, the presentation of claims, character of vouchers accompanying the same, action thereon by the accounting officers of the Government, payment and receipt, were the same as in No‘.'-134, except, it is found, that “settlements for charges on freight shipments on Government bills of lading were in charge of one David A. McLean, head of the freight revising bureau in the office of the general auditor

*354

of the plaintiff [appellant] at San Francisco.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.