Supreme Court of Alabama October 28, 1920, 6 Div. 70. (Warren v. Sims)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-10-1920

SAYRE, J.

[1-3]

By his bill in this cause complainant, appellant here, sought to enjoin defendants from obstructing an alleged public road. Aside from the difficulty which has arisen by reason of the fact that complainant failed to join in the note of submission made after his substitute bill had been filed and answered, we do not find that complainant is entitled to relief. Certainly there has been no formal dedication of this road to the public use, nor has there ever been any official dealing with it as a public road. An intention-to dedicate may be inferred (Trammell v. Bradford, 198 Ala. 513, 73 South. 804): but the history of this road does not sustain such an inference. It was laid out originally by’ the landowner as a matter of private convenience ; and, while neighbors, and even the general public, were permitted to use it, and neighbors from time to time made some desultory repairs, each according to his own pleasure, it does not appear that any considerable number of the public ever used it — there was no reason why they should — gates were maintained across it for several years, being discontinued after the, adoption of stock law. Still later the road for the greater part of its length was changed to a location considerably removed from the original, and was used for a number of years in its new location, and then — for the reason, most likely, that by neglect it had become impassable — it was changed back to its original location. These changes appear to have been made by the landowner and without consultation with any public agency. This history covers a period of 35 years, but there has been no use of ,that part which was changed for as much as 20 consecutive years. However, there has been no change at the point where defendants have created the obstruction of which the bill complains; but the relation of this road to other highways in the vicinity is such that as a public road it can be of very little use unless open throughout its length.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.