Alabama Court of Appeals January 20, 1920, 6 Div. 650. (Morrison v. Jackson)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-01-1920

SAMFORD, J.

[1, 2]

The action was based . on a claim for services rendered by the plaintiff for the defendant at his request in procuring a purchaser for certain real estate belonging to defendant, who was then and there ready, willing, and able

to

comply with the terms of sale agreed upon between plaintiff and defendant, the consideration being the conveyance of certain farm lands, in exchange for defendant's property. The plaintiff contends, and his evidence tends to establish the facts, that defendant employed plaintiff to procure for defendant a party ready, willing, and able to exchange farm lands, acceptable to defendant, in exchange for city property owned by defendant; that he did procure such person; that defendant was tendered farm land acceptable to him and that defendant refused to consummate the transaction, and refused to pay to plaintiff the reasonable value of his services. If the foregoing is true, the plaintiff is entitled to a recovery, for the reasonable value of the services rendered. Stout v. Thornhill, 16 Ala. App. 480, 79 South. 154. But the defendant, on the other hand, contends, and the defendant’s evidence tends to support the contention, that the agreement as finally modified was that plaintiff should procure, in exchange for defendant’s property, farm lands acceptable to defendant and to defendant’s wife, and that defendant’s wife was to be a party to the contract. It is admitted that defendant’s wife never executed the contract, which was drawn up to close the transaction, and in which her name appeared as one of the contracting parties, and it is also conceded that the wife never accepted the farm land as, satisfactory to her, or agreed to the contract. If the above are the true facts, then the minds of the defendant and the party owning the farm lands offered for exchange had never been brought together, and the plaintiff would not be entitled to recover.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.