California Supreme Court June 22, 1920, S. F. No. 8203. (Otten v. Spreckels)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-06-1920

SHAW, J.

The defendant appeals from a judgment in favor of the plaintiff.

The cause has been tried twice. Upon the first trial a verdict was returned for the plaintiff and a new trial was thereupon ordered. From this order the plaintiff appealed. The appeal came before the district court of the third district for decision and the order was affirmed. (24 Cal. App. 251, [141 Pac. 224].) The plaintiff applied to the supreme court for a rehearing and it was denied. The respondent contends that the decision of the district court upon the appeal from the order granting a new trial constitutes the law of the case, binding upon the lower court and upon this court upon the question of the legal effect of the contract set forth in the complaint upon which the

*254

judgment is based. The denial of a rehearing by this court is of no significance as an approval of the law stated in the opinion of the district court of appeal) for the plaintiff in his petition did not complain of the points there decided in his favor, and he now invokes, as the law of the case, certain parts of the opinion which are favorable to him and which this court has had no occasion to consider.

[1]

The decision, nevertheless, constitutes the law of the case to the same extent as if it had been made by this court. It is necessary, therefore, to determine whether or not, upon the second trial, the facts were the same as those upon which the conclusions of the district court as to the law were predicated, since otherwise the doctrine of the law of the case does not apply.

The complaint alleges a contract in writing, which it sets out in full. It then alleges facts which it is claimed constituted a breach thereof and states the amount of the resulting damages. On the first trial this writing was not admitted in evidence. Evidence of oral negotiations leading up to the execution of the writing was given and the trial court treated this as evidence of an oral contract.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.