California Supreme Court September 14, 1920, L. A. No. 5151. (Silvers v. Grossman)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-09-1920

lead-opinion

LENNON, J.

Plaintiff sued to recover damages in the sum of twenty thousand dollars for injuries received in an accident alleged to have been caused by defendant’s negligent operation of an auttimoble. Defendant made answer in which he denied negligence, pleaded contributory negligence, and, for a third and separate defense, alleged that plaintiff and her husband entered into a written agreement with defendant, through his attorney, “whereby the plaintiff and h'er husband agreed to receive and accept from' defendant and defendant agreed to pay to plaintiff and her husband the sum of fifty ($50.00) dollars, in full satisfaction, settlement and payment of any and all claims plaintiff and her husband or either of them had or claimed to have against this defendant by reason of the collision or accident hereinbefore referred' to in defendant’s first and second defenses in. this answer contained, . . . that by the terms of said agreement plaintiff and her husband were fully compensated by the payment to them by the defendant of the said sum of fifty dollars.” The answer then alleged a tender of the said sum of fifty dollars, a refusal to accept the same on the part of plaintiff and her husband, and defendant’s readiness and ability at all times to pay the said sum. A general demurrer to the third defense was overruled, and the case was thereupon tried. The court found the allegations of plaintiff’s complaint, to be true save and except as to the amount of damages suffered by plaintiff,

*699

which was found to he one thousand dollars, hut rendered judgment in favor of the defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.