California Supreme Court November 12, 1920, L. A. No. 6029. (Rudneck v. Southern California Metal & Rubber Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-11-1920
OLNEY, J.
This is an appeal by the defendant from a judgment against it for the purchase price of certain materials found to have been delivered to it under a contract of purchase from the plaintiffs and for which it failed to pay. That a contract was made, that certain materials were delivered under it, and that the defendant refused to pay therefor are admitted. The substantial defense was that the materials delivered were not of the character called for by the contract. The facts are:
The plaintiffs are engaged in the junk business in Kern County, and were the owners of a pile of machine-shop refuse at the town of Taft. The pile, to some extent at least, was made up of “borings and turnings,” borings being the metal sawdust, so to speak, made in drilling into a metal, in this case iron or steel, and turnings being the metal shavings made in turning a metal upon a lathe. The defendant desired iron refuse for the purpose of supplying it to copper or other smelters, which apparently use it in reducing their ores. For this purpose the defendant inspected the plaintiff’s pile of refuse, and, according to the testimony on behalf of the plaintiffs, which was accepted by the court, agreed to buy it. The agreement was confirmed by an exchange of letters reading as follows:
“Dec. 4th, 1917.
“Western Junk Company,
“Bakersfield, Calif.
“Gentlemen:
“As per agreement made with your Mr. Morris Rudnick you have sold us say 150 to 200 tons, more or less, of Borings and Turnings at $8.50 ton, f. o. b. Taft, railroad weights to govern.
*277
“Same to be loaded in gondolas not less than 30-ton minimum. Shipping instructions to be furnished by us.
“Kindly confirm the same by letter.
“Please try and load as clean a stock as you can.
“Yours very truly,
“So. Cal. Metal & Bubber Co.
“By M. Tannenbaum.
“MT/SO.”
“Dec. 5th, 1917.
“Southern Cal. Metal & Bubber Co.,
“Los Angeles, Cal.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit