Supreme Court of Connecticut August 5, 1920 (Williams v. National Fruit Exchange)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-08-1920

Gager, J.

This action is brought primarily to recover damages by a purchaser from the seller of

*302

unsound grapes. The complaint was several times demurred to and amended, and as finally amended was again demurred to, the demurrer was sustained, and judgment was rendered for the defendant Commercial National Bank of California. The allegations of fact are, therefore, to be taken as proved.

The plaintiff in New Haven bought of the defendant Fruit Exchange in California certain grapes to be shipped to New Haven, warranted sound, marketable, proper and suitable for use as food and for making wine. On their arrival in New Haven they were found not to be sound and marketable and suitable for food and for making wine, nor were they sound, marketable and suitable for food and wine when shipped, and when delivered in New Haven were worth $5,000 less than they would have been if as represented and warranted.

The defendant Fruit Exchange, the seller, upon shipping the grapes from California, drew upon the plaintiff to the extent of some $7,000, attached the bills of lading or delivery orders, and had the drafts discounted for his credit by the defendant Commercial Bank. The Fruit Exchange checked against the credit so obtained to its full extent, and the checks were paid by the bank. The Commercial Bank forwarded the drafts, with bills of lading attached, to the first National Bank of New Haven for collection, the First National having previously, at the request of the Commercial National, guaranteed payment by the plaintiff. The plaintiff alleges further, that at the time the Commercial National Bank discounted these drafts, with bills of lading attached, it had knowledge of the facts that the grapes when shipped were not sound and marketable, and were not suitable for food and making wine.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.