Supreme Court of New Hampshire June 1, 1920 (Hodge v. Manchester)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-06-1920

*438

Young, J.

The plaintiffs are the owners of the land in question unless Laws 1913, c. 121 is unconstitutional. This act provides in substance that land which has been, or may hereafter be dedicated to the use of the public for highway purposes, shall be released and discharged of the public servitude unless it is used for public travel within twenty years after it is dedicated to the use of the public. The defendant contends that this act in so far as it is intended to apply to dedications made before it was passed, is in conflict with

art.

23 of the bill of rights; but as the law is understood in this jurisdiction the office of the bill of rights is to protect private rights. Trustees of

Dartmouth College

v.

Woodward,

1 N. H. 111, 129. In short, the office of the bill of rights is to protect individuals from the state — not to protect the state from itself.

Wooster

v.

Plymouth,

62 N. H. 193, 201. Since this is so, the defendant is not entitled to the benefit of

art.

23, for the city of Manchester is a mere political subdivision of the state with no rights except such as the state gives it. If, therefore, c. 121 is unconstitutional, it must be because of some other provision of the constitution.

The only other provision in any way applicable is Part II,

art.

5. This article provides among other things, that “full power and authority are hereby given ... to the said general court, ... to make, ordain, and establish all manner of wholesome and reasonable . . . laws ... so as the same be not repugnant ... to this constitution.”

The test, therefore, to determine whether

c.

121 is forbidden by article 5 of the constitution, is to inquire whether all fair-minded men must agree that enacting this chapter was an unreasonable exercise of legislative power, for there is no provision of the constitution which forbids its enactment in terms.

State

v.

Prince,

77 N. H. 581.

Carter

v.

Craig,

77 N. H. 200, 203..

, Instead of the.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.