Supreme Court of North Carolina December 24, 1920 (Shuler v. Burnhardt Lumber Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-12-1920
Walker, J.,
after stating the case: The first question presented is, ‘Did the judgment in favor of A. T. Davidson, entered November, 1895, estop the defendants there (plaintiffs here) from acquiring title by adverse possession? We are of the opinion that the following cases are clear authority against this position:
Wilson v. Brown,
134 N. C., 400;
Reynolds v. Cathens,
50 N. C., 438; Eddleman
v. Carpenter,
52 N. C., 617,
Scarboro v. Scarboro,
122 N. C., 234. The Court, in
Reynolds v. Cathens, supra,
held that the possession of a grantor in a deed, who" holds over, after his deed was delivered, may be adverse.
Judge
*650
Pearson
in bis opinion, said: “In respect to tbe possession of Sarab Wilkie tbe vendor, under whom botb parties claim, we are unable to see any principle of law wbicb prevents it from being adverse to tbe lessor of tbe plaintiff. Sbe was not bis tenant for years, at will or at sufferance, nor did sbe enter under or obtain possession from bim. As far as tbe case disclosed, sbe continued in possession without any understanding or permission on tbe part of tbe plaintiff’s lessor, notwithstanding tbe deed sbe bad executed, tbe legal effect of wbicb was to give plaintiff’s lessor right of possession, but in defiance of wbicb sbe maintained and continued her possession. It would, consequently, seem that this possession was adverse.” In
Johnston v. Farlow,
35 N. C., 84, it was held that tbe old deed was not color, but that case recognizes that tbe possession can be adverse even after tbe deed was made. Of course, if after tbe execution of a deed with covenants a man can acquire title by adverse possession, be certainly can after a judgment wbicb gives tbe right to a writ of possession. It was held in
Wilson v. Brown, supra,
that tbe possession of a person, wbicb continues after bis land is sold under execution and deed made to tbe purchaser, is adverse to tbe purchaser, but tbe original deed to bim is not color of title after tbe sale.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit