Supreme Court of North Carolina October 13, 1920 (Alexander v. . Vann)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-10-1920
Bkown, J.
We
are-of opinion that Judge Devin was correct in bolding tbat tbe words of tbe letter are libelous of themselves, and actionable because tbe doctrine of qualified privilege does not apply. Tbe undisputed facts are tbat tbe plaintiff was a deputy sheriff of Hert-ford County under Sheriff Garrett at tbe time tbe said libelous letter was written and mailed to tbe sheriff of Pitt County. On 5 May, 1917, Sheriff Garrett received a telegram from sheriff McLawhorn of Pitt County requesting him to arrest one Zemas, a Hungarian of desperate character, a fugitive from justice, who bad murdered his wife, for whose capture a reward of $200 bad been offered. Eley Reid, a colored man, captured Zemas in the swamps of Chowan River, and, single-handed, delivered him to the sheriff of Hertford County at Winton. Sheriff Garrett had been requested to have the prisoner well guarded by two men at the expense of Pitt County. He deputized the plaintiff, a regular deputy, to take the prisoner, to Pitt County, and appointed said Reid, a very-powerful man, to act as guard. The plaintiff took the prisoner and placed him with himself and Reid in the smoker of a white coach, and delivered him safely to Sheriff McLawhorn at Greenville, Pitt County, N. C. The plaintiff, with Reid, then returned to Hertford County. The evidence shows that the plaintiff rode in the white coach, and Reid was in the colored coach except for a short distance, when he first got on the train he was called into the smoker of the white coach by one Mr. Ames, a railroad detective who knew him, and having heard of the capture of Zemas, the Hungarian wife-murderer, asked of Reid the details of the capture. When Reid had related the story to Mr. Ames, he returned to the colored coach and remained there until he reached Ahoskie, his destination.
In the fall, just prior to the publication of the letter in question, J. N. Yann, the defendant in this action, was for the third time defeated by A. E.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit