Court of Appeals of Texas March 18, 1920, No. 1089. (Texas Supply Co. v. Clarke)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-03-1920
lead-opinion
This suit was filed in the county court of Comanche county, Tex., by G. S. Clarke, against the Texas Supply Company, a corporation, for $430. The defendant filed its plea of privilege, alleging that it was a private corporation domiciled in Beaumont, Jefferson county, Tex., and asserted its right to be sued in said county. The plaintiff filed controverting reply to the plea. The evidence was introduced, and the court overruled the plea, and defendant appealed, and has assigned this action of the court as error. The test as to whether the suit could be maintained in Comanche county lies within the following letter and telegrams. No other question is raised here. "December 4th, 1918. "Mr. G. S. Clarke, Box 16, Comanche, Texas — Dear Sir: Replying to your postal in regard to price on scrap iron, we wish to state that we are not in the market at present for mixed iron, but can use No. 1 cast, and if you can furnish us with this, advise where the material will be shipped from and we will then quote you. We are, "Yours very truly, "Texas Supply Company, "H/W. By..........." "Comanche, Texas, 11:23 A. M. Dec. 7, 1918. Texas Supply Co., Beaumont, Texas. Have car number one cast wire offer fob Comanche. G. S. Clarke, 1234 P. M." "Beaumont, Tex., Dec. 7, 1918. G. S. Clarke, Comanche, Texas. Will wire you Monday on Machine cast. Texas Supply Co." "Beaumont, Tex., Dec. 9, 1918. G. S. Clarke, Comanche, Texas. Eighteen fifty Comanche cast car lots. Texas Supply Co." Appellant's proposition is that article 1830, Vernon's Sayles' Stat., governs; it reads: "No person who is an inhabitant of this state shall be sued out of the county in which he has his domicile, except in the following cases" — and that this cause of action does not come within one of the exceptions therein named.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit