Court of Appeals of Texas December 22, 1920, No. 6254. (Union News Co. v. Vinson)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-1920

JENKINS, J.

Appellant was engaged

a.

the business of receiving and caring for baggage for passengers who were intending to take passage on trains, or, as is commonly known, “checking baggage.” Its place of business was in the Katy depot at Waco. Eor such service, it charged 10 cents for each package “checked.” On January 3, 1919, appellee E. W. Vinson, the father of appellee Miss Eleanor Vinson, presented Miss Vinson’s valise to appellant, at its place of business, and received therefor a “check,” bearing a certain numer. This check was handed to Miss Vinson by her father. Miss Vinson was a student at the state university, and was on her way to Austin. The valise contained her clothing of the value of at least $200. Upon delivery of the check, E. W. Vinson paid 10 cents to appellant’s agent. On the face of the check was printed the following:

“The Union News Stand, Waco, Texas. To claim packages present this coupon; charges 10 cents each 24 hours or fraction thereof. No. 7-10-83.”

Shortly before the arrival of the train, Miss Vinson tendered this check to appellant’s agent, and demanded her valise. The agent tendered her an old valise, which was not hers. It was opened in her presence, and was found to contain some old soldier’s clothes. She declined to receive this valise. Her own valise has never been returned to her, nor has she or her father been paid for same.

The case was tried before the court, and judgment was rendered for appellees for $200.

Opinion.

On the back of the check referred to in our findings of fact, there was printed, in small type, the following:

“Duplicate Coupon Agreement. The person accepting this ticket hereby agrees, in consideration of the low rate at which it is issued, that no claim in excess of ($50.00) fifty dollars shall be made against the Union News Company, or its lessor, for loss or injury to the package, valise, or other article, which may have been deposited with it, and for which this ticket has been issued.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.