Texas Supreme Court January 14, 1920, No. 3274. (Lancaster & Wight v. Allen)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-01-1920
*215
Mr. Justice GREENWOOD
'delivered the opinion of the court.
This suit was brought by defendant in error as the personal representative of T. 0. Allen, deceased, against plaintiffs in error as receivers of the Texas and Pacific Railway Company, to recover damages for the death of T. 0. Allen from injuries suffered by him while employed by said receivers in interstate commerce.
Defendant in error alleged, and offered evidence to establish, that T. 0. Allen’s death resulted from defects, due to the receivers’ negligence, in a switch point on the receivers’ track, and in a flange on a locomotive wheel, which caused the derailment of the locomotive, on which T. 0. Allen was discharging his duties to the receivers as fireman.
The defect in the flange of the locomotive wheel, on which defendant in error relied in her pleading and proof, was that' it had become so worn as to cause the locomotive wheel and truck to climb the rail and derail the locomotive.
Plaintiffs in error duly answered and introduced evidence to show that the switch point was not defective and to show that the flange of the locomotive wheel was not worn to the extent required in order to be defective under the Safety Act of Congress and the rules prescribed thereunder by the Interstate Commerce Commission.
The charge of the trial court authorized a verdict for defendant in error on the findings, first, that the flange on the locomotive wheel had become worn, so as to render unsafe the running of the locomotive, or that the switch point had become defective, so as to cause the running of the locomotive to be unsafe, second, that either the defective flange (if defective), or the defective switch point (if defective), caused the engine to be wrecked and T. 0. Allen’s death, and third, that the flange or switch point had been permitted to become defective, by reason of the negligence of the receivers.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit