Supreme Judicial Court of Maine April 9, 1920 (State v. Logan)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-04-1920
Morrill, J.
The respondents stand convicted of the larceny of one automobile tire and two automobile tire tubes alleged in the indictment to be the property of persons to the grand jurors unknown.
The undisputed facts, as shown in the record, are that one Charles C. Deleware, Jr., was the owner of the automobile from which the tire and tubes were taken; that he was killed on Sunday, August 10, 1919, in an accident to said automobile on the highway between Portland and Windham; that after the accident the automobile remained at the side of the highway during the night of August 10th,, and during the following day; that the articles in question were taken during Monday, August 11th. Administration on the estate of said Deleware was granted, and the administrator qualified September 19, 1919, after the finding of the indictment and before the trial in the Superior Court.
At the conclusion of the evidence respondents’ counsel filed a written motion that the jury be instructed to return a verdict of not guilty; this motion was denied, and respondents have exceptions. The case was then submitted to the jury with instructions, to which no exceptions were taken. At the conclusion of the charge respondents requested the following instructions:
“1. The allegation in this indictment that the property alleged to have been stolen was the property of persons unknown is an affirmative allegation to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt by the State.
2. If you find from the evidence that there is a reasonable doubt in your minds whether or not the owner of this property was known at the time alleged by the State, then your verdict must be for the respondents.
*1483. It is not necessary that the respondents prove to you that the owner oí this property was known at the time alleged by the state but only that they make it doubtful in your minds.
These requested instructions were refused and respondents have exceptions;, the evidence is made a part of the bill of exceptions.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit