Texas Commission of Appeals May 12, 1920, No. 114-2970 (Taylor v. Hill)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-1920

McCLENDON, J.

Hood Hill, as plaintiff, brought this suit against W. E. Taylor and H. K. Brown to recover for an alleged shortage in a tract of land conveyed by Taylor to Brown and by Brown to Hill. Upon a verdict upon special issues the trial court rendered judgment in favor of plaintiff against both defendants, which judgment was affirmed by the Court of Civil Appeals, Third District. 183 S. W. 836.

The facts in the case, which appear to be undisputed, except where noted, are substantially as follows: Prior to September 17, 1913, defendant Taylor was the owner of the tract of land in question, and through his agent, Crate Dalton, negotiated a sale of the land to defendant Brown for $11,500, $3,500 whereof was to be evidenced by a vendor’s lien note, $3,000 paid in cash, and the remaining $5,000 represented by the transfer to Taylor of the exclusive right of sale within certain territory of a patented machine known as a “Rollograph,” with which right a certain number of the machines was to be delivered. Brown was unable to raise the cash called for in the agreement, and made an arrangement with plaintiff whereby the latter agreed to become the purchaser of the land, he to assume the $3,500 note and pay the $3,000 in cash, and Brown was to have an interest of $6,000 in the land, together with the right to sell the land at such figure as would realize plaintiff’s outlay and a reasonable profit to plaintiff and Brown’s $6,000 interest therein. There does not appear to have been any writing evidencing this agreement, but it was testified to, both by Brown and Hill; the former testifying that he expected, in so far as his interest in the land was concerned, to make a trade for other land or property. The land was supposed to contain 191 acres, and was so represented by Taylor and his agent, Dalton. At the time of consummation of the trade, however, plaintiff was not satisfied as to the acreage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.