Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 10, 1920 (Stanton v. Hawley)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-11-1920
Cochrane, J. :
The facts in this case may be tersely stated. One Franklin was the general agent to buy and sell cows for the defendant. That fact was known to the plaintiff. Franklin had 'in his possession a cow belonging to the defendant. Franklin claimed to be the owner of such cow by purchase from the defendant and as such owner sold and delivered her to the plaintiff for one hundred and twenty-five dollars'. Plaintiff although aware of the agency did not rely thereon but relied on the ownership of Franklin and gave him in payment for the cow thirty dollars and a receipt for a debt of ninety-five dollars which Franklin was owing him. Defendant as the owner of the cow claiming that he had instructed Franklin not *560to sell her took her from the possession of the plaintiff. The latter brings this action for conversion.
The question is one of title. Although Franklin was the agent of the defendant such agency in respect to this particular transaction is disclaimed by both parties and also by Franklin. The plaintiff and Franklin say that the latter was the owner pf the property which was purchased by plaintiff on the strength of such ownership. The defendant says the property was his and that he had forbidden its sale by Franklin. “It is an old doctrine, from which there has never been any departure, that an agent cannot bind- his principal, even in matters touching his agency, where he is known to be acting for himself or to have an adverse interest.” (Manhattan Life Ins. Co. v. Forty-second Street & Grand Street Ferry R. R. Co., 139 N. Y. 146, 151, and cases there cited.) The finding of the trial court is that the property was owned by the defendant. As Franklin, therefore, did not own the property and did not as agent sell it to plaintiff the latter acquired, no title.
The decision went against the defendant on the ground apparently that he was estopped from denying the authority of Franklin to make the sale.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit