Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 17, 1920 (Kineon v. Bonsall)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-12-1920

Mills, J.:

This is one of several litigations between Bonsall and his stepdaughters, Mrs. Kineon and Mrs. Shiverick, of which several have come to this court within recent years. In fact each recent volume of the reports of this court contains one of those cases. A brief summary of the situation may be helpful.

The mother of the two now young women was widowed when they were very young, but left by her husband with a considerable estate amounting to several hundred thousand dollars. In a few years she married Bonsall and soon thereafter died, leaving a will which gave to him her entire estate; and I have never been able in any of the'several records of those appeals to find any evidence that he ever had any property except that which his wife thus gave him and its proceeds. After a time he brought from New Hampshire his mother and installed her as the mistress of his home; and the two girls grew up together in that home in very much the relation of daughters, with the two Bonsalls as parents; and *112when they reached their maturity married; and to each the Bonsalls made a substantial wedding present, which, by the way, was no more than they ought to have done, as the present had its undoubted source in the fortune of the real mother. The gift to Mrs. Shiverick was of the home at Mamaroneck; and the Bonsalls continued to live there with that young couple. In time a daughter was born to the Shivericks, and when she was about a year old the so-called grandmother, Mrs. Bonsall, took the child out riding against the wishes of the mother, Mrs. Shiverick; and upon being upbraided by the mother for so doing became angry and, refusing to accept the mother’s apology freely tendered in a few hours, left the home and returned to New Hampshire. In a few months she reappeared at the Mamaroneck home and demanded the surrender to her of substantially all the furnishings of it, even the rugs, which had been expressly made for it, upon the claim that Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.