Supreme Court of Georgia May 15, 1920, No. 1746 (King & Hamilton v. Mobley)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1920

Gilbert, J.

J. S. Mobley, on July 14, 1894, made to his wife, Charlotte Mobley, a deed to land, which was recorded July 26, 1894. The consideration was natural love and affection and $1. The $1 was not paid. She testified that her husband gave her the property; that she and her husband lived on the land until his death in 1917, and she continues to live on it. She mortgaged it in the year 1901. Eor the •years 1910 to 1916, inclusive (except 1915, when no tax return was made), the husband returned the property for taxation in his own name. He made several mortgages on the land. The last of these was to secure two notes to King & Hamilton, which were sued to judgment oh November 24, 1916. The fi. fa. from one of them was levied on the land mentioned, and Charlotte Mobley filed a claim Neither King nor Hamilton knew of the deed to Charlotte Mobley, or that she claimed the land, until after their mortgages were taken. It was agreed that the jury find the property subject to the fi. fa. if it was subject to the mortgage securing the debt represented by the fi. fa. The court directed the jury to return a verdict finding the property not subject; and a judgment having been entered thereon, King & Hamilton, plaintiffs in fi. fa., excepted. Held:-

1. Under the evidence a finding that the deed from J. S. Mobley to Charlotte Mobley was voluntary would be authorized; and the record *257of a voluntary deed is not notice to an innocent third person who acquires, for a valuable 'consideration, a contract lien. against the property. Actual notice is required by law in order to give priority to a voluntary deed. Avera v. Southern Mortgage Co., 147 Ga. 24 (92 S. E. 533).

No. 1746.

May 15, 1920.

Claim. Before Judge Gower. Wilcox superior court. September 26, 1919.

Hal Lawson, for plaintiff. Eldridge Cutts, contra.

2. Although a deed purports to be for a valuable consideration it may be shown to be in reality voluntary only. Finch v. Woods, 113 Ga. 996 (39 S. E. 418); Leggett v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.