Supreme Court of Georgia December 20, 1920, No. 1893 (Harvey v. Thornton)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-12-1920
Beck, P. J.
Mrs'. Anna Harvey brought ejectment against Mrs. J. R. Thornton, to recover a certain tract of land. After the conclusion of the evidence the court directed a verdict for the plaintiff. A motion for new trial was made, which .was heard by the successor to the 'judge who directed the verdict. The judge hearing the motion passed an order setting aside the verdict and .granting a new trial, to which the plaintiff excepted.
Counsel for the plaintiff insists that the judgment granting a new trial should be reversed on the ground that the evidence heard upon the trial of the case demanded the yerdict rendered by the jury under the direction of the court. At the trial the plaintiff introduced in evidence a deed from Georgia Beavers to Anna J. Harvey, the plaintiff, conveying the premises in dispute. The defendant introduced in evidence a deed to herself from the *781same grantor, Mrs. Georgia Beavers, conveying the same property, but which was junior in date to the deed to Mrs. Harvey. The junior deed, however, upon which the defendant relied was hied for record September 12, 1913, and recorded on that date, while the senior deed was not recorded until the year 1919. However, it is urged upon the part of the plaintiff that it is conclusively shown by uncontradicted evidence that Mrs. Thornton, the grantee in the junior deed which had been duly recorded, had notice of the existence of the prior instrument convejdng the same land to Mrs. Harvey, and therefore that the court was authorized to direct the verdict rendered. The evidence upon which this contention is based is contained in the testimony of J. T. Henley, which is as follows: “I leased the property [the property in dispute] from Mr. Harvey for two years, and I talked about buying it from him. It was always known as the Harvey property. Everybody there knows that that knows it. Yes, the fact that Mrs. Beavers had given Mrs. Harvey a deed — that matter was discussed in the presence of Mrs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit