New York County Courts February 15, 1920 (Mechanicville War Chest, Inc. v. Ryan)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-02-1920
McKelvey, J.
The several motions submitted by both sides present troublesome and somewhat complicated questions of law; for which reason, as well as because of the fact that this case will probably have *450some bearing upon other similar controversies, I have decided that, in passing upon these motions, I should briefly state upon the record the reasons which prompt me to the decision about to be made; to the end that if any of these cases shall be reviewed in the appellate courts, those courts may have some direct evidence before them of the reasons upon which this determination is based.
The defendant, by signing the so-called pledge card, became chargeable with knowledge of the fact, and he frankly admits that he knew that the War Chest was an organized body of some character, intended to fulfill some purpose in the community; for his promise is to pay to “ the Mechaniciville War Chest for the purposes for which it is organized;” and the payment is to be made to “ F. S. Clute, Treasurer, or his successor'in office.”
The defendant is an intelligent man, experienced in business affairs, at present a merchant in the city of Mechanicville, and either now, or at one time, a prominent director of one of the banks of that city. He knew, or he could have ascertained in the exercise of reasonable diligence, and is, therefore, chargeable with at least implied knowledge of the fact, that the payee named in the card was the treasurer of a corporation organized for the purposes stated in the charter or certificate of incorporation, which was easily accessible, because necessarily upon the public files; and he also became chargeable at least with implied knowledge of the fact that the by-laws of the corporation were, or were likely to be, in existence; for the purposes of a corporation are necessarily stated in its certificate of incorporation, and the duties and obligations of its members are, in large part, fixed by its by-laws.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit