Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court January 9, 1920 (Berube v. New York, New Haven, & Hartford Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1920

De Courcy, J.

The plaintiff, as administrator of the estate of his minor son, William M. Berube, seeks to recover damages for the conscious suffering and death of the intestate, who was struck by a train of the defendant at the so called Mount Hope Avenue crossing in Fall River on Sunday, October 7, 1917, about 9:45 P. M. By order of the trial judge a verdict was returned for the defendant on all the evidence; and the only question raised by the report is whether that ruling was right.

In order to determine the controlling issue, whether the intestate was an invitee or merely a licensee in walking across the track when he was injured, it is necessary to consider the history and use of this crossing. In 1862 Samuel B. Allen owned a farm in the neighborhood. On March 11 of that year the city of Newport purchased from Allen a portion of his land, as part of the proposed location of the Newport and Fall River Railroad Company, which land was later conveyed by the city to the Old Colony Railroad Company, the predecessor in title of the defendant. The railroad location, about eighty-two feet in width, cut through Allen’s farm, leaving some eleven and one half acres on the westerly side, toward Mount Hope Bay. ' The farm house was on the easterly side, ten hundred or twelve hundred feet from the railroad. There was no “Mount Hope Avenue” at that time; and when it was laid out (when or by whom this was done does not appear) it became necessary to move the house back to the north side of the “Avenue.” There was no building on the eleven and one half acre lot west of the railroad. That portion of the farm was used for raising hay, although at times four or five acres of it were used for garden purposes.

Samuel B.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.