Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court April 5, 1920 (Ryder v. Brockton Savings Bank)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-04-1920
Braley, J.
The plaintiff, the wife of the mortgagor Henry H. Ryder, having joined releasing dower in the mortgages, three in number, given by him on his real property to the defendant bank, the foreclosure of which had been begun when the bill was filed but has been suspended during the litigation, can maintain the bill as amended for leave to redeem. Newhall v. Lynn Five Cents Savings Bank, 101 Mass. 428, 430. Fitcher v. Griffiths, 216 Mass. 174. R. L. c. 187, § 22.
But, a fourth mortgage having been given to the defendant Ellis, who as between himself and the bank is a second mortgagee, which has been foreclosed by Ellis under the power of sale, the plaintiff, who did not join in the mortgage, also claims that she is entitled to redeem from this mortgage, because, the equity of redemption being extinguished by the foreclosure, subrogation to the rights of the bank will not furnish any protection against the complete destruction of her dower rights. A wife, even after a sale of the mortgaged premises where she joins in the mortgage, may, during the life of her husband, bring a bill to redeem and test the validity of the foreclosure, for if the foreclosure stands her inchoate right is lost. Pierce v. Chace, 108 Mass. 254. Kopp v. Thele, 104 Minn. 267. Mackenna v. Fidelity Trust Co. 184 N. Y. 411. It is true that the right rests on marriage and the seisin of the husband through whom the wife acquired an interest in the premises which she can protect only by redemption. If she re*480deems, the husband’s title is not transferred to her, although by subrogation she succeeds to all the rights of the mortgagee. Kopp v. Thele, 104 Minn. 267. It is plain, however, that the fourth mortgage is not an incumbrance on her right to dower: a right inhering not merely in the equity of redemption but in the entire property subject to the mortgages to the bank.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit