New Mexico Supreme Court March 19, 1920, No. 2341 (State v. Hunt)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-03-1920

OPINION OF THE COURT.

ROBERTS, J.

This is an 'appeal from a conviction of murder in the second degree. Three grounds of error are relied upon for a reversal. The first is in the ad- ■ mission of certain evidence in rebuttal. The deceased, Chester Bartell, was killed by the appellants along a trail through the forests of Grant county. The killing was admitted, and self-defense was interposed as justification. In rebuttal two witnesses were permitted to testify to the finding of a bullet at the scene of the homicide more than six months after the date thereof, and the bullet was put in evidence. The objection made to the admission of this evidence upon the trial was that it was not proper rebuttal. This objection is urged here, and also it is further contended that the finding of the bullet more than six months after the homicide was so remote in point of time as to make evidence thereof inadmissible. This second ground is here urged for the first time, and, under the well-established rule, is not available to the appellants.

[1] As to the question as to whether there was error in the admission of this evidence in rebuttal when it should have been put in in chief, it is well settled that it is within the discretion of the . trial judge to admit in rebuttal, or at the time for rebuttal, facts and circum-stances which are not strictly in rebuttal and which should be or might have been offered in chief. 16 C. J. 868; Goldsby v. United States, 160 II. S. 70, 16 Sup. Ct. 216, 40 L. Ed. 343; State v. Riddle, 23 N. M. 600, 170 Pac. 62.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.