New Mexico Supreme Court April 23, 1920, No. 2281 (State v. Crosby)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-04-1920

OPINION OP THE COURT.

BAYNOLDS, J.

The defendant, Stephen Crosby, was indicted in Chaves county for the murder of one Julian Shafer on October 14, 1917. At the November term of the district court for said county he ivas found guilty of manslaughter and sentenced. From the verdict and sentence defendant appealed to this court.

The facts out of which this case arose are substantially as follows:

At the time of the killing the deceased, Julian Shafer, was occupying and using school section 36, the section on which the killing occurred. Said section had a fence on the south line and a fence bn the west, but the fence on the west was not on the true line, but was about 20 feet further west than the true line between sections 35 and 36. Thera was no fence on the north and east of the section. The defendant had leased land, and was entitled to graze and use the same, to the north and east of said section 36, and had leased water from one Graves, who owned the section adjoining 36 on the south.

On Friday afternoon prior to the killing on Sunday, the defendant moved approximately 500 head of cattle from his home to a point north and west of section 36. The cattle remained there until late Saturday afternoon, when his employe, “Doc” Roberts, started the cattle south for water in the direction of the Graves house. On the following morning, Sunday, the defendant and Roberts left the defendant’s home to look after the cattle and to ascertain if they had gone to water. They rode north and west of section 36 about .a mile and a half in the vicinity of a schoolhouse, where they separated, and began to gather what cattle had not gone to water, intending to drive them south to the water.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.