Arizona Supreme Court February 25, 1920, Criminal No. 472 (Apodaca v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-02-1920
CUNNINGHAM, C. J.
The appellants are soldiers. Pfior to December, 1918, they were stationed at Whipple Barracks, an army post adjoining Prescott. At about said date the duties assigned to them were what is known as “kitchen police.” About 3 o’clock in the afternoon of the last Sunday in December, 1918 (December 29th), these appellants went from the post to the city of Prescott and returned to the post at 10:30 the same evening. On that night, December 29, 1918, Manuel Gonzales was killed by having been beaten to death with blunt instruments. The homicide was committed at the house of a colored woman, Nellie Campbell, the place .being one of ill repute. The body of Gonzales was thrown into a shed or coal-house on the rear of the Nellie Campbell lot. On the night of the said 29th of December the defendants visited the Nellie Campbell house. While they were there a fight occurred in the house between Apodaca and Manuel Baca, another soldier of the post. Griego also participated in the fight, either as helping Apodaca or in trying to separate the two. *275Baca was bruised and Ms head was cut, his wounds bleeding profusely. His wounds were treated at the post.
The defendants reached the post shortly after Baca got there, and they were present and assisted in dressing Baca’s wounds. During the fight in which Baca took part the furniture in the house was disarranged. A dispute exists with regard to whether or not the deceased, Gonzales, participated in the fight. Nellie Campbell made irreconcilable, conflicting statements at different times as to the time of night the fight took place at her house. On the trial she fixed the time at 8 P. M. At the inquest on the body of Gonzales she fixed the time at midnight or a little later, and at another occasion she fixed the time at a different, intermediate hour.
I shall briefly set forth the testimony for the purpose of considering the instructions requested and refused.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit