Arizona Supreme Court May 5, 1920, Civil No. 1765 (S. H. Kress & Co. v. Evans)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-05-1920

BAKER, J.

(After Stating the Facts as Above.)— The appeal in this case presents a contest over the application of the parol evidence rule. During the course of the trial the court, over the objections of the defendant, admitted testimony on the part of the plaintiff to the effect that plaintiff met Mr. O. W, Kress, a member of the defendant company, in his room at the Adams Hotel in the month of February, 1917, and there discussed the business being done by the defendant’s store at Phoenix. Mr. Kress produced the arrangement sheet for the signature of plaintiff. Plaintiff read the instrument, and stated that the arrangement sheet did not specify what his percentage for the year 1917 was to be. Whereupon, Mr. Kress replied: “Oh, that will be just the same as it was last year; you can trust S. H. Kress & Co. for that.” Whereupon, plaintiff said: “All right, with that consideration, I will sign it.” Further testimony was admitted tending to prove that defendant’s store, under plaintiff’s management in the year 1917, and prior to the conversation referred to, had done some $80,000 worth of business. It was also testified that the plaintiff was paid $1,836, being one and one-half per cent of the business of $125,000, done by the store for the year 1916. The defendant contends that proof of the oral contract was inadmissible because it tended to alter and change the terms of the written contract between the parties. The plaintiff contends that the oral contract was collateral and independent of the written contract, and constituted the inducement for the execution of the written contract, and, being such, was not violative of the parol evidence rule.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.