District Court, D. Alaska March 1, 1920, No. 1898-A (Libby v. Cramer)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-1920

JENNINGS, District Judge.

An injunction in this case is prayed for on the ground that the act of the Alaska Legislature (chapter 29, Sess. Laws 1919), entitled “An act to impose a tax upon male persons in the territory of Alaska for school purposes, providing means for its collection, and declaring an emergency,” is unconstitutional.

Attacks on the acts of a Legislature as being unconstitutional do not meet with much favor in any event; but any assault by injunction- upon the act of a Legislature whose object and purpose is to raise revenue for the support of the government comes especially under the ban, and an extraordinarily clear case has to be made in order to warrant the court'in granting such injunction.

It is well settled by the decision of the highest court in the land that a court will not enjoin the collection of a tax on the sole ground that the legislative act levying the tax is unconstitutional. Dows v. City of Chicago, 11 Wall. 108, 20 L. Ed. 65.

Mr. Beach, in his work on Injunctions says:

“The reason that a court of equity will not enjoin the collection of an unconstitutional, tax is that if the act is unconstitutional *221the officers enforcing it are trespassers and liable in damages to be ascertained in a court of law.” 2 Beach on Injunctions, § 1207.

There must be, in addition, some well-recognized ground of equitable jurisdiction.

The only other possible ground for equitable interposition set forth in the complaint is the categorical, statement that plaintiff will be subjected to a multiplicity of suits. I do not think such bare statement is sufficient.

It will be seen that the act, the constitutionality of which is attacked, does not require the employer to furnish”a list of his employees, nor does it require him to pay the poll taxes of his employees.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.