District Court, D. Alaska May 26, 1920, No. A-172 (Seattle Merchants' Ass'n v. Larson)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-05-1920

BROWN, District Judge.

Upon the hearing of the demurrer the attorneys for defendants urged that it appeared from the face of the complaint that the plaintiff’s assignors were foreign corporations, and were not alleged to have made *265such compliance with the Alaska corporation laws, and therefore the demurrer should be sustained. This is the only ground of the demurrer which it is necessary to consider.

In the case of Van Schuyver Co. v. Breedman, 5 Alaska, 260, it is held that a foreign corporation engaged in business in the territory of Alaska could not maintain an action therein, unless it affirmatively appeared that it had complied with such corporation laws, and that the reason that such laws in many of the states are held invalid is that they are in contravention of the constitutional provision that a state may not impose any burdens upon interstate commerce, or regulate interstate commerce, but such right is retained by the Congress of the United States. The Alaska corporation law was enacted by the Congress of tire United States,' and, Congress clearly having authority to legislate on this subject, the enactment cannot be held to be unconstitutional.

It was suggested by counsel in such case that Congress acted only as a local Legislature, and did not intend that the act should have such effect; but such law, being enacted by Congress, the legislative authority having constitutional authority to enact the law in question, must be deemed to be binding and effective. A recent case from the Fourth Division of Alaska, to wit, Ross-Higgins Co. v. Protzman and Gordon (not reported) also holds that such corporation' may not maintain an action in the courts of Alaska without such compliance.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.