Ohio Court of Appeals July 6, 1920 (Vondenberger v. Schaaf)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-07-1920
Hamilton, J.
Error is prosecuted here to reverse the judgment of the trial court, based on an instructed verdict, in a case wherein a tenant sought to hold a landlord for personal injuries suffered by her.
The record discloses the following state of facts. The plaintiff in error, Alma Vondenberger/who was plaintiff below, was a tenant of the defendant and occupied two rooms on the second floor of defendant’s property. Adjoining the property was a factory building, the wall of which extended beyond the wall of the property occupied by plaintiff, forming an “L.” Defendant had constructed-a wooden fire-escape for the employes of the factory building, the platform of which was in the “L”, built on a level with and extending from the window of the rooms occupied by plaintiff to the window of the factory building. There was a rope swung across over the platform, and, at the time of the renting of the property by plaintiff, plaintiff’s husband made some inquiry of the representative of the landlord with reference to the wooden fire-escape, as to its safety, and the use of the rope swung across, and was told by him that the fire-escape had been inspected and approved by the proper authorities and was perfectly safe; that the rope was to hang things on and had been used by the former tenants for that purpose, and that plaintiff could use the platform for the same purpose. To get out on the platform from the rooms of the plaintiff, it was necessary to climb through a window. The plain*287tiff had been occupying the premises for considerable time, when, on an occasion in which she was on the platform for the purposes suggested, the platform gave way, precipitating her to the ground, 'and as a result she claims to have been seriously injured. The platform was no part of the premises rented by plaintiff, and, as above stated, was constructed for fire-escape purposes.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit